How to Date Intentionally in NYC When Everyone Seems to Be Getting Engaged

There’s a point in your twenties and early thirties when the group chat goes from “What are we doing Friday?” to “Did you see who just got engaged?” And suddenly you’re on the subway home from a date you knew was going nowhere before your coffee even arrived, thinking, How is everyone else doing this?

Dating in New York City is hard. You can have a great time with someone on a Thursday and then spend two weeks trying to find another Thursday you’re both free. And even when you do like someone, it’s easy to wonder who else is out there. There are a lot of people here! That’s part of what makes this city fun, and it can also make it harder to give one person your attention long enough to find out if you like them.

Then there’s the fact that you came here to do something with your life. You care about your work. You’ve built friendships you want to keep showing up for. And somewhere in all of that, you’d love to meet someone you can come home to. Of course you’re wondering where dating is supposed to fit.

Take another look at your list

I love a list. I also think some of us have a list for our future partner that describes someone we’ve already dated, or someone we decided we were “supposed to” want a long time ago.

Think about what you’d actually want to be true on an ordinary Tuesday with this person. Maybe you want to be able to tell them something awkward without spending the next hour wishing you could take it back. Maybe you want someone who makes plans and follows through. You can learn a lot more about those things over a cup of coffee than you can from somebody’s job title or social media posts.

So if someone grew up differently from you, works in a field you know nothing about, or looks a little different from the person you’ve always pictured, see if you’re curious enough to get to know them. Attraction matters. So do your boundaries and what you both want out of a relationship. There’s room to be surprised by the rest.

Go places you’d be happy you went anyway

Try a coffee shop in a different neighborhood. Go to the book club your friend keeps telling you about. Say yes to the birthday party where you only know the person whose birthday it is. And if you like the book club, go back! It’s much easier to start a conversation when you’ve already spent one evening arguing about the same book.

If you like using the apps, think about how they could fit into a week you’d actually want to live. Maybe you check them for a few minutes after your Sunday coffee instead of opening one every time you’re waiting for the train. Maybe you leave a night open every other week so that when you do want to meet up with somebody, there’s a time you can offer. And if you’ve been messaging someone you’re excited about, you can just ask them to get coffee. Really.

Give yourself a minute when the comparison hits

You can be thrilled for your friend and cry a little on the way home from their engagement party. You want something, and seeing someone else get it can hurt. I’d give yourself a minute to feel that before opening an app and deciding you have to find somebody by next weekend.

If you’re already seeing someone, here’s a question I like. If nobody had gotten engaged this month, would I be excited to see this person again? You might realize you’ve been so busy wondering whether they’ll choose you that you haven’t had a chance to figure out how you feel about them.

And if the same thing keeps happening with different people, that’s something we can talk about in relationship therapy. We can look at what happens when you really like someone, what you do when you feel unsure, and how hard it might be to ask directly for what you want.

I think we can make dating work for you. That might start with one evening you’re actually looking forward to, in a part of the city you’d be happy to spend time in, with someone you’re curious about. You can see how it goes from there.

If you’d like to talk through what keeps coming up for you when you date, my team at LEL offers virtual therapy in New York.


Dating in New York Is a Lot. Let’s Talk About It

Maybe you keep ending up in the same kind of relationship. Maybe you’re tired of reading into every text. Or maybe you really want to meet someone and have no idea how to make dating fit into your life right now.

That’s all fair game in therapy. Our team at LEL Therapy offers virtual relationship therapy across New York. We can talk through what keeps coming up for you and what you actually want from dating.

Take the first step and reach out for a free consultation call through the link below!

Previous
Previous

How to Support a Partner With a Current or Past Eating Disorder

Next
Next

How OCD is Actually Trying to Protect You, Not Hurt You